I read this open letter on the rejection of the proven, life saving technologies vaccination and genetically modified organisms.
Dear Every American Who Doesn’t Believe in Science:
I know you are smart. I know you care about your kids, your family, your pets. I know you are a basically decent human being who wants to do right and contribute to society. And because I know these things, I’m going to try very hard to understand why you refuse to believe in scientific fact, rather than berate you and call you names.
The funny thing is, I actually think I’m reasonably good at seeing the other side of any issue. There are a few issues where I struggle, but even then, if I’m honest with myself, I can intellectually understand the other side of the issue and why my friend or colleague has positioned himself on that side.
Regarding immunizations and genetically modified organisms, I can’t.
Yes, I view these two issues – though they are definitely in different industries – as intertwined. Why? Because the people who are anti either of them have a blatant disregard for science and I just don’t understand that.
Scientific consensus on both of these issues is that both are safe. Immunizations are safe for the vast majority of people. GMOs are safe for everyone.
Do you understand what scientific consensus is, my friend? That means that most of the scientists (maybe even those who don’t usually agree) believe the safety of GMOs and immunizations to be fact. It’s beyond dispute. The data has proven safety beyond a shadow of a doubt so that scientists no longer squabble over this issue.
I appreciate what this writer is trying to do and agree with her positions, yet I cannot help but consider that her arguments are somewhat flawed, or perhaps insufficient is a better way to put it. Basically, her argument is that Science has decreed that vaccines and GMO’s are safe because there is a consensus and all the scientists say they are safe. In my view, this is a misunderstanding of what science really is and how it should work.
Science is not a body of lore handed down on stone tablets at Mount Sinai by God or some famous scientist. Science is a method of inquiry used to learn facts about the natural world. It does matter what Einstein or Newton or some other famous scientist says, no matter how great their contributions to science. They can be wrong. It does not matter what the consensus is. The consensus could be mistaken. Not so very long ago, the scientific consensus was that disease was caused by imbalances of bodily humors and bleeding was the most effective treatment. The only thing that matters, or should matter in science is the observations that are made and the logical inductions that are made from those observations Ideally, scientist should be interested in “just the facts”. I think the best arguments on any subject are those based on just the facts.
So, what are the facts about vaccination. Before the widespread introduction of vaccination, people fell sick and even died from a variety of infectious, contagious diseases’ smallpox, measles, whooping cough diphtheria, to name just the ones that spring immediately to mind. These diseases have been virtually wiped out since vaccines for them have been developed. Smallpox, the deadly disease that people feared, is now extinct. Only in backward regions, filled with ignorant and superstitious people, such as the darkest regions of California do these diseases continue to plague humanity.
There have been no credible studies linking vaccination with autism or any other chronic illness. The one study that did propose such a link has been discredited and retracted. This does not mean that there isn’t such a link.There could well be one that has not yet been discovered. But, consider the fact that millions of children have been vaccinated with no ill effects. There may be some danger in being vaccinated, nothing in this world is completely safe, but the dangers associated with not being vaccinated are far greater and more certain. Any rational consideration of the risks and benefits of vaccination must come to the conclusion that the benefits outweigh the risks. If you do not get your children immunized, you are putting them at risk of catching preventable diseases that could cause permanent damage to their health, or even death. Those are just the facts.
- Quick Vaccine Math (goodmath.org)
- A TED-Ed Animation Explaining How Vaccines Work to Help the Body Stave Off Infections, Illness, and Disease (laughingsquid.com)
- California legislators want to make it way harder for parents to opt out of vaccines (vox.com)
- Michael Gerson: The public good versus individual freedom (utsandiego.com)
- Ben Carson: Vaccines are Good Medicine, Not Political Issue (bighealthreport.com)